Public Exhibition

Firstly – a big ‘Thank You’ to all who made last Saturday’s exhibition a roaring success. We will have a full report shortly in the next mailshot, and here on the website. Meanwhile, see the press release below for a summary; Secondly, as a result of much information gathered at the exhibition, we will be busy finalising our strategy for the letter writing campaign that will be triggered by any planning application – further details will be in the next mailshot…


Stop The Marina! Press Release 9 Monday 12th November 2007

IT'S NOT TOO LATE TO STOP THEM! was the theme of a public exhibition hosted by Stop The Marina! and Friends of The Bay last Saturday. Both groups have been actively campaigning against the proposed marina development at Penlee Quarry for well over two years. Almost two hundred people including, MP Andrew George and local councillors, were in attendance.


Much anxiety was expressed by those attending about the implications of the development, including increased traffic through Newlyn, Mousehole being 'cut off' by the proposed lifting bridge, and access for emergency services. There was also growing concern about rumours of proposals to build a new road to service the quarry around the back of Tredavoe; and also fears that the water in the quarry 'lake', which would need to be drained before the development takes place, is highly toxic, a view which was put forward by local senior mining geologist Dr. Terry Cotton, who also attended the exhibition. According to Dr Cotton -  ‘the water, which is likely to be highly acidic, could do untold damage to marine life in Mount's Bay’.

Additional material was provided by town councillor and keen local diver Heidi Worth representing the Silver Dolphin Diving Centre, who brought some fascinating photos of marine life taken off Roskilly beach and was in constant conversation with members of the public throughout the day.  If the development goes ahead, the creation of a channel for the marina would effectively destroy Roskilly as a diving area and would probably mean the end of the eelgrass beds, a vital marine habitat protected by the Berne Convention.  The beach was voted Britain's top dive site by national magazine Sports Diver in August this year.

There was also an exhibition by Penzance Harbour Users of their alternative proposal for a Penzance marina, incorporating many exciting ideas for the regeneration of the harbour area.

"The message we are trying to get across to the public is that there is still time to stop this development," said organiser Adam Whaley. "People seem to have become very confused ever since Marina Developments Limited gained permission to resume quarrying in December last year. They can see the site being landscaped, and as a result they think the development is going ahead, but, as yet, there have been no planning applications either for housing or a marina. We are ready for the next stage of the campaign, which is to get in as many objections to the planning as possible once it is submitted, and we are trying to raise public awareness to that end."

Further information on the campaign can be found on Stop The Marina!’s website: www.stopthemarina.co.uk

 


We are gratified that The Cornishman has printed an article based on our press release above. However, note the adjustment - 'nearly two hundred' has become 'about a hundred' - why this has been changed we can only guess?

We also note with interest that MDL now state that the planning application that, we understood was due in early November, will now 'be lodged in the Spring'. If this is true it will allow us a little more time to refine our tactics and gather more information to back up our case.

MARINA COULD DO 'UNTOLD DAMAGE' TO MOUNT'S BAY

Printed on page two of The Cornishman - 15 November 2007

A public exhibition organised by opponents of Newlyn's proposed marina and housing development at Penlee Quarry attracted about 100 people to St Peter's Church at Newlyn on Saturday.Stop The Marina and Friends of The Bay, set up the exhibition to "raise awareness of the implications of the development".

Andrew George, MP for St Ives, also attended the event, which included a photographic exhibition of marine life at Mount's Bay.

Dr Terry Cotton, a mining geologist, suspects the flood water in the quarry, which will mix with the sea if the development goes ahead, is "likely to be highly acidic" and could do "untold environmental damage in Mount's Bay. However, Edward Illiffe, managing director of MDL, has disputed his claims.

"Dr Cotton has never tested the water in the quarry and we have, and we actually think that he is wrong," said Mr Illiffe.

"If this was a public exhibition why weren't we invited?" he added.

Adam Whaler, a campaigner with the Stop The Marina! group, said many of the exhibition's visitors were worried about the increased traffic and there were fears expressed that the proposed lift-bridge would cut Mousehole village off from emergency services at regular intervals in the day.

"The message we are trying to get across is that there is still time to stop this development," he said.

"People see the site being landscaped and they think the development is going ahead, but, as yet, there have been no planning applications either for housing or a marina."

Mr Illiffe said a planning application for the marina would be lodged in the spring. He told The Cornishman that an agreement with a property developer was not likely to be reached until then.



Note: two reader's inane comments (reprinted below) have been sent in. If you want to add your enlightened own to the The Cornishman's website we strongly urge you to do so - click here.

The ludditeism being displayed by the stop the marina group is symtomatic of the backward thinking which has dogged west cornwall for decades and prevented its economic regeneration. Presumably these are the same fools who voted no to unitary status for the county.
Mr I J Mc, Penzance

I think having a marina in Newlyn is fantastic. A positive step for the future.. I am fed up with people opposing change in the area... ... I was born and bred in Newlyn and worked on a seasonal basis in Mousehole.. I love the place,however, its time to move forward. I work in Falmouth for a yacht building company, who are environmentally conscious, employ local people to carry out refit work on beautiful yachts. The owners in turn spend money in the area with local businesses as well as offering employment/travel opportunities on board their yachts. It makes, social, economical and environmental sense to move this marina project on... Who wants to look at a disused quarry for another 15 years? The area is depressed enough - come on people shape up or ship out!!!
Mrs A, Newlyn